IDL vs Schema

IDL_vs_Schema.md

IDL vs Schema

Disclaimer: ChatGPT generated document.

The terms IDL (Interface Definition Language) and schema are often used in data serialization, communication protocols, and API design, but they serve different purposes and operate at different layers.

---

🔍 1. What is an IDL (Interface Definition Language)?

An IDL defines *interfaces and APIs*—how components or services communicate.

It describes:

• Methods/functions available.
• Parameters and return types.
• RPC or message formats.
• Sometimes, exceptions or errors.

Think of it as a contract for communication. It defines how to call something, not just what data looks like.

Examples:

Technology	IDL Example
gRPC	.proto files
CORBA	.idl files
D-Bus	XML-based IDL
Thrift	.thrift files
COM	.idl files

Example (gRPC proto):

service Greeter {
  rpc SayHello (HelloRequest) returns (HelloReply);
}

message HelloRequest {
  string name = 1;
}
message HelloReply {
  string message = 1;
}

This describes the API, not just the data.

---

📦 2. What is a schema?

A schema describes only the *data structure*.

It defines:

• Field names
• Types
• Required/optional
• Constraints
• Default values

A schema does not define methods or communication rules, only how the data is shaped.

Examples:

Technology	Schema Format
JSON	JSON Schema (.json)
XML	XSD
Avro	.avsc
SQL	CREATE TABLE
Protobuf	Also used as schema (message definitions)

Example (JSON Schema):

{
  "type": "object",
  "properties": {
    "name": { "type": "string" },
    "age": { "type": "integer", "minimum": 0 }
  },
  "required": ["name"]
}

This defines the data, without saying how it is used.

---

🔄 Overlap and Confusion

Some technologies (e.g., Protobuf, Thrift, Avro) combine IDL and schema in the same file. That’s why people sometimes get confused.

For example, in a .proto file:

• message blocks = schema
• service blocks = IDL

---

🧠 Summary Table

Aspect	IDL	Schema
Purpose	Defines how services communicate	Defines structure of data
Contains	Services, methods, RPCs	Fields, types, validation
Used for	API contracts, RPC, IPC	Serialization, validation
Layer	Interaction layer	Data layer
Example	service Foo { rpc Bar(...) }	message Foo { int id = 1; }
Changing impact	Affects integration logic	Affects data format

---

💡 Practical Perspective

If you are designing...	Use
A gRPC service	IDL + schema (.proto)
A REST API body	Schema (JSON Schema/OpenAPI)
A DB schema	SQL Schema
A messaging protocol	Schema (and possibly IDL if RPC)
A C++ header for ABI	IDL-like concepts

---

🧩 Final Analogy

🎭 IDL is like describing the menu and how to order 📦 Schema is like describing what’s inside each dish

---

If you’re comparing for C++ integration:

• Use IDL when working with RPC frameworks (gRPC, Thrift).
• Use schema when defining serialization formats (JSON, Avro).
• Sometimes you’ll work with both—schema for DTOs and IDL for the interface.